The separation of church and state began with the Greeks. However, their religion seemed to tie more closely to their political affairs as things in Greek society were often done for the pleasure of the gods. The Jews also had early ideas of this separation because of their religious persecution. Could you even imagine a country where people are punished or exiled for religious practices?
While we must obey our laws, what about higher laws? This is where church and state tend to mix in the United States. Like Antigone's reasoning, "I disobeyed because the law was not the law of Zeus nor the law ordained by Justice", things like abortion and the death penalty seem to conflict with the higher laws of Christianity. They should not be an issue if church and state are really separate but they never can be completely. Most law makers will draw off their personal lives and beliefs. They must also appeal to the desires of the citizens or they will be challenged and possibly taken out of office.
Things like slavery have proved to be unjust in the past and MLK argued in a fashion after Antigone. Higher law trumps human law.
"Render unto Ceasar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's."
Sunday, November 13, 2011
Tragedy on Wall Street
CEOs and major companies often fall victim to hubris (pride, excessive self-confidence). Like Oedipus, they bring it upon themselves by boasting and saying things like, "We will do it again this coming decade." Wrong.
Hubris comes with a sense of being above the world, like Icarus. Aristotle explained that tragidies rely on the pounishment of successful but flawed heroes who reach for godly heights. Demonstrated by the Time Magazine curse, man can only reach so high. Once he attains a godly height and makes it known to the world, there is no where to go but down.
"Hubris goes out of its way to let you know of its existence, while humility does not."
Hubris comes with a sense of being above the world, like Icarus. Aristotle explained that tragidies rely on the pounishment of successful but flawed heroes who reach for godly heights. Demonstrated by the Time Magazine curse, man can only reach so high. Once he attains a godly height and makes it known to the world, there is no where to go but down.
"Hubris goes out of its way to let you know of its existence, while humility does not."
Antigone's Tragedy
Antigone's story is just as tragic, if not more tragic than her father/brother's, because she was born into the situation left behind by Oedipus. After the banishment of her father, the suicide of her mother, and the deaths of her brothers, there couldn't possibly be more terrible things in store for Antigone. Oh but there were.
Antigone defied Creon's orders because of the idea of a higher justice. She claimed that denying her brother a proper burial, they were defying the orders of the gods. She chose to defy her uncle instead and honor ther gods and her brother. This idea of justice and the injustices ordered by Creon, makes readers feel for Antigone. She had done nothing wrong to deserve her past and was condemed by justice. By defying Creon's orders, she had done the honorable thing. Most would see her courage and devotion as great. Instead, they turned her story into tragedy.
Like her mother and brothers, Antigone became another victim to follow in the wake of Oedipus. She would committ suicide like her mother. Creon's son would then stab himself. His mother would also take her own life. The story of Antigone became more tragic than her father/brother's.
Antigone defied Creon's orders because of the idea of a higher justice. She claimed that denying her brother a proper burial, they were defying the orders of the gods. She chose to defy her uncle instead and honor ther gods and her brother. This idea of justice and the injustices ordered by Creon, makes readers feel for Antigone. She had done nothing wrong to deserve her past and was condemed by justice. By defying Creon's orders, she had done the honorable thing. Most would see her courage and devotion as great. Instead, they turned her story into tragedy.
Like her mother and brothers, Antigone became another victim to follow in the wake of Oedipus. She would committ suicide like her mother. Creon's son would then stab himself. His mother would also take her own life. The story of Antigone became more tragic than her father/brother's.
Thursday, November 3, 2011
Free Will or Fate?
One of the big questions concerning not only tragedy but life in general is: free will or fate?
When presented with decisions, especially big desisions, people draw on many things. Decisions are influenced by three major factors: choices presented, life experiences, and human instinct. Typically, one has many choices.
For example, when I get dressed in the morning, I have an abundance of socks to choose from. Black socks, blue socks, white socks, spotted socks, fuzzy socks, tall socks, etc. Now, based on past experiences, I may decide that the fuzzy socks are too big for tennis shoes and pinch my toes. I may also rule out tall socks because they irritate me. Now left with only the black, blue, white, and spotted, I may choose based on my instinct. For some reason, I always choose the black socks. I have no idea why. I just like them better.
Now don't get me wrong, I am a big believer in free will. I don't think life is linear and there is no way your course could be preset. There are too many factors that are pure science, not chance, that will have an impact on your life. Hurricane Katrina devistated and displaced so many people. Weather is science. They were victims of science and chance, not a predetermined incident.
While people do have their own free will and past experiences, instinct will always be present. The number one human instinct is survival. Except for those few valiant heroes who sacrifice themselves for the good of other people, the majority of the population puts their survival needs first. As the heroes demonstrate, the survival instinct is not infalliable. It can be combatted by reason that comes out of past experiences. It can be defeated by pride, justice, stupidity, and any number of things. Whenever one is presented with options, human instict will battle with everything else.
What about when you really don't care what an outcome is or when you don't know what to choose? Your instinct will contribute it's opinion, but it often falls to default, or chance. Some mornings I just reach in the sock drawer without looking, don't you?
When presented with decisions, especially big desisions, people draw on many things. Decisions are influenced by three major factors: choices presented, life experiences, and human instinct. Typically, one has many choices.
For example, when I get dressed in the morning, I have an abundance of socks to choose from. Black socks, blue socks, white socks, spotted socks, fuzzy socks, tall socks, etc. Now, based on past experiences, I may decide that the fuzzy socks are too big for tennis shoes and pinch my toes. I may also rule out tall socks because they irritate me. Now left with only the black, blue, white, and spotted, I may choose based on my instinct. For some reason, I always choose the black socks. I have no idea why. I just like them better.
Now don't get me wrong, I am a big believer in free will. I don't think life is linear and there is no way your course could be preset. There are too many factors that are pure science, not chance, that will have an impact on your life. Hurricane Katrina devistated and displaced so many people. Weather is science. They were victims of science and chance, not a predetermined incident.
While people do have their own free will and past experiences, instinct will always be present. The number one human instinct is survival. Except for those few valiant heroes who sacrifice themselves for the good of other people, the majority of the population puts their survival needs first. As the heroes demonstrate, the survival instinct is not infalliable. It can be combatted by reason that comes out of past experiences. It can be defeated by pride, justice, stupidity, and any number of things. Whenever one is presented with options, human instict will battle with everything else.
What about when you really don't care what an outcome is or when you don't know what to choose? Your instinct will contribute it's opinion, but it often falls to default, or chance. Some mornings I just reach in the sock drawer without looking, don't you?
Tuesday, November 1, 2011
Tragedy Comes With Greatness
"It must be a paradox that the happiest, most vigorous, and most confident ages which the world has ever known-the Periclean and the Elizabethan-should be exactly those which created and which most relished the mightiest tragedies."
Tragedy is not an expression of despair, but a celebration of hope and human improvement. It seems only fitting that the greatest tragedies come out of the greatest ages. Those or greatness have the most to lose. It is interesting that literatary tragedy seems to only affect the nobility. It seems as though the upper classes can fall as well as hope. It is interesting that tragedy never seems to affect the peasants in, possibly suggesting that when you have nowhere to fall, there is no hope for improvement either.
Tragedy is not an expression of despair, but a celebration of hope and human improvement. It seems only fitting that the greatest tragedies come out of the greatest ages. Those or greatness have the most to lose. It is interesting that literatary tragedy seems to only affect the nobility. It seems as though the upper classes can fall as well as hope. It is interesting that tragedy never seems to affect the peasants in, possibly suggesting that when you have nowhere to fall, there is no hope for improvement either.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)